Hi Frank,
On 11/29/2010, I sent you an email similar to the one you are about to (hopefully) read yet again. That email had been in regards to you having posted a secret that said “She lied. I never raped her.” I got no reply. This week, you posted a secret that says, “My sister lied about being raped to hide the shame of being a 20-year old virgin.” My mind froze when I saw those words. I was filled with rage, directed partially at the person who had the audacity to write it, but more so at you, a person with such visibility and influence, for having shared it with millions.
I have to admit, I had stopped checking PostSecret after receiving no response to my last email (this is after having been an every-Sunday follower for years), but this week, I was spontaneously compelled to check up on the site. I was so angry upon seeing that secret, I simply exited the page and tried to decide if I should send you another email or not. I came to the conclusion, clearly, that I had to. Please, bear with me here, as I am going to explain again what the problem with these “secrets” are and would appreciate it if you gave what I am saying some thought. This is an issue extremely important to me, and I’m sure an uncountable number of your fans, and it is something that should be important to you.
I spent years reading PostSecret every week, and have no memory of ever seeing a secret of someone admitting they were raped, or admitting they raped someone—not a single one—but I am sure both have been submitted. I won’t question why I haven’t seen these invisible secrets posted (or at least not to my memory), instead I will jump to why it is so despicable to post secrets like the ones aforementioned in the first paragraph—
We live in a rape culture, and this is a culture that transcends all political and social barriers. There is not a place in the world you could step foot where you will not find survivors of rape being blamed for the crime that was committed against them. This is unlike almost any other crime. It is a crime of oppression, power, and injustice and that pulls through the legal system and throughout the minds of everyone that hears or sees the word “rape.” The reason rape is so successfully belittled and brushed under the rug is because of the belief system that permeates throughout our world and the minds of our people. Things like “but what about the men who are falsely accused of rape?!” “What about the girls who make up being raped for attention?!” These are myths. These are not the stories that occur, nor the stories that need to be told.
For every person that “lies” about being raped, wherever that person may be, there are 10,000 people who WERE raped and are being told by their friends, family, judges, lawyers, police, detectives, and doctors that they must be lying, that it must have been a misunderstanding, or they must have been asking for it. Seeing secrets like this posted are going to make it all the more terrifying, all the more misleading, and all the more offensive to those who HAVE been raped, those who DO need a voice, and those whose stories NEED to be told. I know this is a project about controversy, about a shock factor, and about discussion, but none of that was accomplished with this secret. I fear for the impact this secret (and the one from last year) has had on survivors of rape who have suffered and may still be suffering but have not spoken out. For a project so grounded in the basis of empowerment and community, I would expect a better effort to be put into acknowledging the oppressive world we live in, and the fact that some voices need to be heard above others because they have been silenced for so long.
I could go on forever in this email, simply because of how many disgusting ideas were brought up in this one secret, but I will stop for now and hope that anything I said was considered and thought about. You did not share a secret this week, nor a confession, you shared someone speaking on behalf of their sister and perpetuating one of the most cruel and unjust ideals that ruin our societies and the safety of our people. I pray and hope her sister was not actually raped, because there is nothing worse than having those that are supposed to be closest to you disbelieve your story. Rape is not about sex, nor virginity, it always has been and always will be a vicious crime of power committed by every day people disguised as our neighbors and friends.
Signed,
Talena
PS. If you could please, I would love to have an “Email Response” posted on the site under that secret saying the following (since I assume my whole email could never be posted): “I WAS raped, and I hope this secret doesn’t scare anyone away from saying that.” Thank you.
I would love it if anyone else who is enraged by this would send him an email at frank@postsecret.com (even just a couple sentences).